The recent decision by the Frederick City Board to allow non-citizen voting in municipal elections has sparked significant controversy among residents. As the largest city in the state to adopt this measure, the decision has drawn criticism not only for its content but also for the way it was enacted. Many residents, myself included, believe this charter amendment represents a grossly irresponsible overreach by city leadership.
Unlike Takoma Park, the first city in Maryland to permit non-citizen voting in 1992, Frederick’s decision did not include a public referendum. Takoma Park’s approach allowed its residents to have direct say in this consequential policy shift. Frederick’s choice to bypass this step has left citizens excluded from the democratic process.
Despite a limited 40-day window for a petition drive, approximately 2,000 city residents signed petitions opposing the measure and calling for a referendum. These signatures represent a clear message: Frederick’s residents want their voices heard on this matter. Through conversations with the petitioners, it is evident they believe the amendment was rushed through without adequate public input or transparency. Ironically, a measure intended to empower the disenfranchised has left U.S. citizens in Frederick feeling exactly that—disenfranchised.
The most vocal opponents are naturalized citizens, who are frustrated they went through considerable legal hurdles to become citizens, only to have their votes diluted by those who may or may not ever make the commitment to citizenship.
Legal precedent will condemn this irresponsible decision. Earlier this year, New York City’s non-citizen voting law was overturned as unconstitutional. If the largest municipality in the country could not legally sustain such a policy, it is prudent for Frederick to consider whether this measure aligns with broader constitutional principles.
Frederick’s residents deserve a voice in decisions that shape the future of their community. Allowing non-citizen voting without a public referendum undermines trust in local governance and sets a troubling precedent. It is imperative for the city’s leadership to revisit this decision and ensure that the constitution is followed, and citizen voices are heard.Sign the petition to stop Non-Citizen Voting in Frederick City: https://www.frederickvoter.com/